A draft comes back with the customer's full name, the date of their appointment and a line about what they ordered. It reads warmly. It's also a problem, because anyone can read it.
Your reply is publicly posted under the customer's review.1 Treat it like a sign in your shop window.
Details about the customer
Leave out anything that points to a particular person:
- their full name, if they used only a first name or a username
- phone numbers, email addresses and home addresses
- booking times, dates and staff names that let others work out who they are
- anything about their family, health, finances or legal situation
The customer may have chosen to share some of this in their review. That doesn't mean you should repeat it. Repeating a customer's details can be a privacy problem.
Privacy rules differ by country and by type of business. Rules about handling personal information are set by official bodies, such as the OAIC in Australia, the ICO in the UK and the FTC in the US. Check the official source for your country, or ask your lawyer. This site gives general information only.
Details about the job or the account
A public reply isn't the place for:
- invoice amounts, payment status, refunds or what the customer owes
- order numbers, account numbers or login details
- what was done in a job, if it tells strangers about the customer's home or situation
- internal notes, such as "this customer has complained before"
An AI draft often adds this kind of detail to sound thorough. Delete it. Say you'll look into the matter and invite them to contact you directly.
Health and sensitive services
If you run a clinic, a counselling room or any service tied to someone's health, don't confirm that a person was your client or discuss anything about their care. Keep the reply to a general, kind line and take the rest to a private channel. Front-desk replies only ever need to thank, apologise in general terms, and give a contact route.
Things the tool might make up
A model's fluent text can look factually sound and still be wrong.2 In a reply, that can mean:
- a made-up policy, such as "we always refund within a set time"
- an invented explanation for what went wrong
- a named staff member who didn't do the job
- a legal claim, such as saying the review is defamatory
Don't let a draft say anything about law, fault or compensation. If a review raises a legal threat, get proper advice before you reply publicly.
Things that can get a reply rejected
Google reviews replies, and if a reply isn't approved you'll be asked to edit it.1 The source doesn't list the rules. What follows is this site's own advice, not Google's criteria. Keep the tone calm. Leave out links to your sales pages, offers and any pressure to change the rating.
Things that aren't fair play
Don't tell the customer to remove or change the review as a condition of a fix. Don't threaten them. Google also asks owners not to report a review just because they disagree with it or dislike it.3 A disagreement belongs in a calm, factual reply, not in a report.
How to tell the tool what to avoid
Add these lines to your brief:
Don't include the customer's name, order or booking details, prices or any health or personal information. Don't state what happened unless I've given it to you. Don't offer refunds or compensation. Don't mention legal action. Invite them to contact the business directly.
Then check the draft against that list yourself. The tool can slip, and the reply is yours. A fuller routine lives in this checklist for editing.
Reference list
- Manage customer reviews, Google Business Profile Help
- Large language model, Wikipedia
- Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile, Google Business Profile Help