Skip to content

What to Give an AI Tool Before It Drafts a Reply

Up to date as of 17 November 2026

The draft comes back generic, or worse, it gets your business wrong. Nearly always the cause is the same: the tool was handed a review and nothing else.

Instructions to an AI model are called prompts, and refining them can produce more accurate, relevant or useful output.1 For a review reply, that means a short brief. No clever tricks. Just the right facts.

Building the brief for the toolPaste the review as writtenAdd the facts you've confirmedSay who is replying and the toneAdd a past reply as an example
Four short parts are usually enough.

Start with the review itself

Paste the whole review, word for word. Don't summarise it. A summary can drop the one detail the customer cared about.

Say which platform it's on if the tone differs between them. A reply on a map listing and a reply on an industry directory can both be short and polite, but you may want different warmth.

Add the facts you've checked

This is where drafts are won or lost. List only what you know to be true:

  • what the business does, in one line
  • your opening hours or service area, only if the reply might mention them
  • what actually happened, if you've looked into it
  • what you're willing to offer, if anything
  • how the customer can reach you, such as a general business email or phone number

Models can write fluent text that reads as sound and is factually wrong.2 A gap in your brief is where that tends to creep in. Tell the tool, in plain words, "don't mention any offer or refund" if you haven't decided on one.

Say who is speaking and how

Tell the tool who's replying and what voice to use. Some examples of tone notes:

  • friendly and brief, like a local owner
  • calm and formal, like a clinic front desk
  • warm but never jokey
  • no exclamation marks, no emojis

On Google, the reply appears as if the business replied, and your personal name isn't shown.3 So decide whether you'll sign off with a first name anyway, and tell the tool what to do. If a platform shows the owner's name, you may want a sign-off. That's a choice, not a rule.

Prompt guides also mention role assignment, which means telling the model what part to play.1 "You're the owner of a small family-run cafe" is the kind of line that works. Keep it plain.

Give it a past reply as an example

Examples inside a prompt are another recognised technique.1 Paste in one or two of your own replies that you were happy with. Tell the tool they show the voice you want, not the words to repeat.

Pick examples that differ. If both open with "Thanks so much for your kind words", the draft will too.

Say what to leave out

A good brief also holds things back. Tell the tool:

  • not to invent names, dates, prices or policies
  • not to repeat the customer's full name, order details or contact details
  • not to admit fault or blame the customer until you've decided
  • to keep the reply short

Don't paste in anything you wouldn't want a stranger to see. Customer phone numbers, account numbers, and health or payment details don't belong in the brief at all. Read the terms of the tool you use to see how it handles what you type. A separate page, details to keep out of replies, goes through the list.

A brief you can reuse

Keep a short template in a note on your phone or computer. Fill in the gaps each time:

Draft a short public reply to the review below, for [business type]. Voice: [tone]. Facts I've confirmed: [facts]. Don't invent anything else. Don't include names, order details or contact details. Here's an example of our voice: [past reply]. Review: [paste].

Then read the result critically. The checklist on editing before you post shows what to look for.

Reference list

  1. Prompt engineering, Wikipedia
  2. Large language model, Wikipedia
  3. Manage customer reviews, Google Business Profile Help